Letters - 20 November 2026
'In essentials unity, in non-essentials liberty, in all things charity.'
Community standards
Friends who post comments on thefriend.org are deemed to have consented to our community standards, which can be found in our Terms & Conditions. Please familiarise yourself with these ten simple guidelines so that we can keep thefriend.org a safe, respectful and inclusive platform for discussion.
Comments breaching these standards will be removed, and persistent breaching of these standards will result in the comment facility on the letters page being suspended.
Enslavement
Charles Mountbatten-Windsor’s recent description of the ‘great suffering’ of the enslavement of an estimated ten to twelve million Africans barely touches the sides. Some 3.3 million people were traded by British traders.
Culpability and historic responsibility for actions of previous generations is complex – a cultural process, as my Quaker antecedents might say, of Truth and reconciliation, a process unlikely to be served by soundbites or slogans.
As a child I was haunted by what looked like manacles hung on the wall of a family archive, and the thought of antecedents being directly involved. I experienced genuine relief at not being a direct descendant of a branch of the family who clearly ran a plantation in Barbados.
The truth about the manacles was more interesting. Uncle Frank (Francis Meynell, a lieutenant in the navy) had in fact been an illustrator who documented navy missions liberating enslaved people from the hell-holes of slave ships after the British empire abolition. At around the same time Elizabeth Fry, from a banking family, was working hard to ameliorate conditions for women and girls on British ships deporting them to Australia – perhaps not shackled but subject to sexual slavery during and after deportation. There is a branch of Quakers who still take pride in the practical mechanism devised by Quaker bankers to compensate owners of enslaved people for their financial losses, which was apparently instrumental in the Abolition Act finally being passed in 1833. There was no compensation for the liberated enslaved people, obviously. As a Friend, I have a hard time taking any pride in that but as we know political horse-trading can be messy.
I know I was relieved when the manacles Uncle Frank brought home were taken down from the walls of the family archive and stored in safe keeping, until such time as the right place can be found for them.
It was astonishing to discover a couple of Uncle Frank’s illustrations, and a diary, held in storage at the National Maritime Museum in Greenwich. I know this familial proximity has prompted a lot of self-reflection and I hope informs my worldview beneficially. I wonder if such artefacts were dusted off and placed in an exhibition, might it assist with this historical reckoning, which I anticipate isn’t going away any time soon?
Clare B Dimyon
Party politics
Our Friend Keith Braithwaite’s condemnation of the motion on Zionism passed at the Green Party summer conference (Letters, 6 November) contains much to commend it, and much that is entirely unreasonable.
The claim, for example, that Friends who are Green Party members, including one of six Quaker MPs, are members of ‘an antisemitic organisation’ because of one motion, is entirely unworthy of him. The Labour government has consistently, diplomatically and via trade of all kinds, supported or refused to condemn the actions of a murderous, genocidal regime in Israel. Should Quaker Labour MPs and members leave the Labour Party?
The Green Party of England and Wales supports unilateral nuclear disarmament in line with Friends’ concern for peace. No other national party does. Should Friends therefore join it in huge numbers? Please may we have nuanced, temperate, prayerful reflections in letters to the Friend?
Mario May